|
ROBERT
LAMM
Die Kritiken
|
Last Update:
03.03.2001
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Zur Einleitung Robert Lamm's
"Critic's Choice" aus "Chicago VI":
Critic's Choice
-Robert Lamm-
What do you want
What do you want
I'm givin everything I have
I'm even trying to see if there's more
Locked deep inside
I'll try
I'll try
Can't you see, this is me
What do you need
What do you need
Is someone just to hurt
So that you can appear to be smart
And use a steady job
Play God
Play God
What to you really know
You parasite
You're dynamite
An oversight
Misunderstanding what you hear
You're quick to cheer
And volunteer
Obsurdities, musicals, blasphemies
Oh Lord
Save us all
What do you want
What do you want
I'm givin every thing I have
I'm even trying to see if there's more
Locked deep inside
I'll try
I'll try
Can't you see, this is me
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Michael Schlüter
aus "Sounds" 1974:
|
Robert Lamm ist Sänger, Stückeschreiber
und Tastendrücker in Chicago. Er hat seinen besten weißen
Zwirn angelegt und auch die feschen weißen Schuhe. Mit enem knappen
Dutzend sorgfältig ausgewählter (?) eigener Texte unter dem
Arm ist er dann ab ins Studio, um sein SOLOALBUM zu produzieren.
Die Lyrics hat er zum Mitlesen
auf der Innentasche der Platte abdrucken lassen. Sie sind zurückhaltend
("Love Song"), witzig ("Crazy Way To Spend A Year"), trivial ("Some
Day I'm Gonna Go"), manchmal leicht stupide ("Skinny Boy", "City Living").
Musikalisch am gelungensten sind
das stampfende "Crazy Way", das wiederholt von einigen Wiener Stehgeigern
unterbrochen wird und natürlich (!!!) "One Step Forward, Two Steps
Back" über dem knallhart heruntergerockten Baß. Nicht schlecht
der gebossanovate "Love Song" mit einem eindrucksvollen akustischen
Gitarrensolo von Alan de Carlo. Reizvoll auch der Einsatz der hysterischen
Pointer-Sisters-Vocals im Kontrast zu Lamms metallischer Stimme im "Skinny
Boy" und das totale Freak-Out, das sie auf "City Living" veranstalten.
Nervend bisweilen Larnms stakkato abgehärnmerte akkordhafte Pianotechnik
und das mehrfache Zugeigen einiger Nummern durch das Orchester. Na ja,
als das Album dann eingespielt war, hat er sich den Hofphotographen
bestellt, auf dass dieser ihn in seiner schicken Montur ablichte, mit
Weichzeichner und allem im Great-Gatsby-Stil auf Vorder- und Rückseite
des Covers und sogar auf dem Label Fab.
Im großen Ganzen gesehen,
hätte Lamm sich vielleicht doch noch zwei oder drei textlich und
musikalisch geistvollere Stücke einfallen lassen sollen und dann
eine Scheibe ohne flops machen können. Stimmt doch, Gina? Ja, sagt
sie. Na also.
|
|
William Ruhlmann
"All Music Guide" 12/1999:
|
At the time of the release of Robert
Lamm's debut solo album, Skinny Boy, in 1974, it was easy to think that
the singer-songwriter-pianist intended to launch a solo career, even
though no announcement was ever made that he was leaving Chicago. The
group was at the peak of its popularity at the time, having recently
released the third of five consecutive #1 albums, Ch icago VII. But
Lamm, who had written most of its early hits-"25 Or 6 To 4, " "Does
Anybody Really Know What Time It Is?, " "Beginnings, " "Saturday In
The Park"-was facing increasing competition from other writers in the
band. And Skinny Boy, though its title song (also the album's single)
had appeared on Ch icago VII, was a departure from the group's sound,
especially in that it entirely eschewed the use of a horn section (though
Chicago guitarist Terry Kath was all over it). The music was identifiably
Lamm's in its mixture of Beatles-style pop-rock with elements of Latin,
funk, and gospel, all cued to his percussive piano playing. The lyrics
were full of distress: The word "crazy" appeared in four songs, including
two titles, "Crazy Way To Spend A Year" and "Crazy Brother John, " and
"insane" appeared in one. Lamm's voice often sounded strained, which
contributed to the sense of a tormented soul but didn't do much for
the album's commercial potential. But there also seems to have been
little or no promotion (which is not surprising, since the album originally
came out on Chicago's label, Columbia, which had little incentive to
foment insurrection in its most successful group), and Skinny Boy quickly
disappeared.
Bewertung: 2 Sterne (OK)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Matthias Inhoffen
aus "Stereoplay" 3/1996:
|
Weniger Fortune als Bill Champlin
auf "He
Started To Sing" beweist
der Chicago-Veteran Robert Lamm auf seinem neuen Soloalbum.
"Life Is Good In My Neighborhood" wirkt vor allem in den rockig-funkigeren
Passagen etwas steif. Immerhin befanden sich bei der Aufnahme Top-Profis
in der Nachbarschaft: David Foster sowie die Produzenten Phil Ramone
und Randy Goodrum.
Bewertung: Interpretation: 6-7,
Klang: 7-8, Repertoirewert: 6. (Bestnote: 10)
|
|
William Ruhlmann
"All Music Guide" 12/1999:
|
Skinny
Boy, the first solo album
by Chicago keyboard player and singer Robert Lamm, came out at the height
of the group's popularity in the mid-1970s and never had much of a chance
for independent success. Lamm continued with the group, his early prominence
in which came to be eclipsed by Peter Cetera's. By 1995, when he finally
released his second solo album, Li fe Is Good In My Neighborhood, on
Chicago's own record label, the group had not had a new album out in
four years. Lamm seemed to have labored long and hard over the release,
which was full of well-written and powerfully sung original songs. In
particular, his social conscience, expressed in early Chicago material
but not much since, was given free rein, as he reflected on the state
of things "In This Country, " lamented "All The Years" that had gone
by without improvement, and wondered whether "Jesse" (Jackson, presumably)
could improve matters. But as that reference (in a song copyrighted
1988) suggested, by 1995 much of the album was dated. This was especially
true of its sound and arrangements, which were dominated by the icy
keyboards, searing guitar work, and drum programming typical of the
early and mid-1980s arena-rock style of performers like Foreigner, Journey,
and Starship. If Life Is Good In My Neighborhood had been released by
a major label at that time, it might have been competitive. By 1995,
it seemed a throwback.
Bewertung: 3 Sterne (Good)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
William Ruhlmann
"All Music Guide" 12/1999:
|
Though Robert Lamm's second solo
album, Life
Is Good In My Neighborhood,
was released in 1995, 21 years after his first, it sounded like it might
have been made as much as a decade earlier, implying either that Lamm
was out of touch with current musical trends or that he'd been working
on it for a long time. But his third album, In My Head, following a
mere four years later, sounded much more contemporary. In fact, the
tracks assembled by producer John Van Eps, with their occasional hip-hop
and trip-hop rhythms, sometimes suggested that the listener was about
to hear from a current rap act rather than a pop-rock veteran in his
mid-fifties. But from the opening song, the philosophical "Will People
Ever Change?, " it was clear that this was the same singer-songwriter
who had sung "Does Anybody Really Know What Time It Is?" in his butterscotch
voice three decades before. Chicago, the band he co-founded and to which
he remained faithful, hadn't released a new album since 1991, and that
seemed to be enough time for him to come up with an album's worth of
excellent material, including: "Sacha, " a lovely ballad of parental
love; "The Best Thing" and "Swept Away, " romantic duets with Phoebe
Snow; and several songs that pondered the meaning of existence and the
state of society. Best of all was the one song Lamm didn't write, "Watching
The Time Go By." Written by Carl Wilson of the Beach Boys and Gerry
Beckley of America (like Lamm, two longtime band members), the song
reflected autobiographically on the passage of time, echoing John Lennon's
"Watching The Wheels." Though, as usual, there were no indications that
Lamm was about to leave Chicago, In My Head suggested for the first
time that he had rediscovered the songwriting talent that launched that
group and was using it to examine his times as trenchantly as he had
in the 1960s and '70s. "You know I've still got the passion, " he sang
in the catchy "The Love Of My Life, " and the album bore him out.
Bewertung: 5 Sterne (Best Of Artist)
|
|
Matthias
Inhoffen aus "Stereoplay" 12/2000:
|
Bei den Rockjazz-Pionieren Chicago
war Robert Lamm eine treibende Kraft. Und heute? Anders als sein Ex-Bandkollege
Peter Cetera, der als Solokünstler den seichten Pop-Kurs der späten
Chicago fortführt, zeigt Lamm am Mikrofon beträchtlichen Biss: Funky
Rock mit vertrackten Metren und aufmüpfiger Gitarre („Will People Ever
Change") steht da neben feinem Soulpop mit Phoebe Snow als Duettpartnerin.
Und ,Watching The Time Go By", in dem Beach Boy Carl Wilson einen seiner
letzten Auftritte hatte, ist edelster Harmony-Pop. „In My Head" beweist:
In Lamms Kopf geht es äußerst rege zu.
Matthias Inhoffen
Bewertung: Musik: 7-8, Klang: 8, Repertoirewert: 7 (Bestnote:
10)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
William Ruhlmann
"All Music Guide" 02/2001:
|
The best track on In My Head (1999),
the third solo album by Chicago singer/keyboardist Robert Lamm, was
"Watching the Time Go By," a song on which he was joined by
Gerry Beckley of America (who wrote it) and Carl Wilson of the Beach
Boys. The tune suggested a potential partnership by these three rock
veterans that comes to fruition on Like a Brother. The teaming frees
the performers to explore unusually personal topics; the songs are full
of reminiscences and reflections on past experiences that give way to
observations on the present characterized by determination and benevolence.
Beckley's "Watching the Time" (a new version of "Watching
the Time Go By") and Lamm's "Life in Motion" both look
back on youthful illusions in the light of later wisdom. But it is Wilson
who has a disproportionate presence on the record, with four co-compositions
(to Lamm and Beckley's two each) and five lead vocals (to Beckley's
three and Lamm's two). This is far and away Wilson's best non-Beach
Boys work, and some of the best work of his career. His songs are full
of a sense of a generous love, the kind one feels for family rather
than a romantic partner. "I Wish for You" might be written
for a child, while "They're Only Words" warns that love must
be acted on, not just spoken about. The album's most striking song is
"Like a Brother," Wilson's tribute to his brother Brian, in
which he discusses the oddity of earning applause every night for performing
music written by his usually absent sibling. "Like a Brother"
deserves a place in any Beach Boys fan's collection.
Beyond the songs as compositions, the album is stunning aurally, the
three singers proving to have a wonderful blend and, coming from three
bands in which they had to learn a lot about harmony and vocal arrangement,
to be experts in the creation of luscious vocal music.This
is the work of studio types who know how to make highly produced rock,
and though there are simple, unadorned moments, for the most part this
is densely arranged pop/rock that does justice to its creators' abilities.
And yet the songs are some of the most introspective that any of these
talents - each of whom has, to some extent, been subsumed within a group
context - has ever performed.
The tragedy, of course, is that Wilson's death makes this a one-off
effort.
Bewertung: 5 Sterne
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|